The legal battle between Gibson and Dean Guitars continues to heat up as the case returns to court following an appeal from Dean. This latest development means the case will be reconsidered, with the potential to significantly impact both companies.
To recap, several years ago, Gibson sued Dean over the copyright rights to the distinctive shapes of their V and Z guitars. The court initially ruled in favor of Gibson, banning the sale of these guitar shapes in the United States. This decision was a major blow to Dean, which was already undergoing ownership changes following the death of its previous owner. The V and Z models were a significant part of Dean's guitar catalog and featured in several artist-endorsed lines. Consequently, the court ruling led to the termination of several endorsement contracts.
Dean's appeal introduces a twist to the case. The appeal has resulted in the case being reopened, with previously excluded evidence now permitted for review. This evidence, dating back to before 1992, suggests that the V and Z shapes are generic and therefore not subject to patent protection.
The reactions from both parties have been telling. Gibson has remained composed, while Dean has prematurely declared a total victory. This premature celebration could be seen as optimistic, as the final outcome is still uncertain. The reintroduction of additional evidence could potentially favor Dean, but it remains to be seen how the court will rule this time.
As the case starts anew, with expanded evidence on the table, the guitar industry watches closely. The outcome of this legal battle could have far-reaching implications for both companies and the broader market for iconic guitar shapes. The "Guitar War" is far from over, and the next chapter promises to be as contentious as ever.
Stay tuned!
FOLLOW US ON:
